What’s Considered a Strong DNA Match?

What’s Considered a Strong DNA Match?

Genetic genealogy can help you break through brick walls in your research by identifying new relatives, allowing you to infer information about your common ancestors.

But due to the considerable size of MyHeritage’s database, you may receive thousands of DNA matches. How do you know which ones you should focus on?

The plainest answer to this question is: it depends what you’re looking for.

By and large, most genealogists are interested in DNA matches that are most closely related to them and with whom they share the greatest number of ancestors. In that case, you would look at the overall percentage of shared DNA and the length of the shared segments — as we’ll explore below.

But perhaps you’re trying to trace a particular line of lineage, and you want to identify DNA Matches who share a particular common ancestor. If so, you’ll need to do some deeper sleuthing. We’ll touch on that in this article, too.

Look at the family tree

But before we dive into genetics, it’s important to know that the family tree information provided by the DNA Match may be more significant to your research than anything else.

For example, if you have a 3% match with someone who has only 3 people on their family tree, but a 0.4% match with someone who has an extensive family tree, the latter might be much more helpful than the former — and you’ll be able to tell right from the match card. You’ll be able to see how many shared Smart Matches, ancestral surnames, and ancestral surnames you have. It might even have a Theory of Family Relativity™, which corroborates all the data available through MyHeritage to come up with a plausible theory for how you may be related to the match.

For this reason, before you look at any of the DNA data, it’s a good idea to review the match and look for genealogical information first. Check to see if there’s a Theory of Family Relativity™, and if not, look at their family tree, review the shared ancestral places, surnames, and Smart Matches™.

In lieu of solid genealogical information, genetic information can come in handy.

How much DNA do cousins share?

The more DNA you share with an individual, the more recent your common ancestor was. You share around 50% of your DNA with your parents and children, 25% with your grandparents and grandchildren, and 12.5% with your cousins, uncles, aunts, nephews, and nieces.

A match of 3% or more can be helpful for your genealogical research — sometimes even less. You can find the percentage of DNA you share with a given DNA Match right on the match card.

You will also see that figure expressed in centimorgans. Centimorgans (cM) are units of genetic linkage between two given individuals. For example, if you share 1800 cM with an individual, that means you share around 25% of your DNA with them. A strong match will have around 200 cM or more.

Shared segments

However, it’s not only a matter of how much DNA you share; it’s also a matter of which segments of DNA you share.

Longer segments of shared DNA indicate that your common ancestor was probably more recent. If you have 2 matches who both share 7% of your DNA, and one of them shares a few long segments with you while the other shares many small segments, the first one is a stronger match.

The second case may indicate that you have multiple distant ancestors rather than one close ancestor — something that happens in endogamous communities (where people marry within the group), such as the Ashkenazi Jewish population. In populations like these, experts require a higher percentage of shared DNA and longer segments to confirm a strong match, because the shared DNA may not necessarily point to a recent common ancestor.

The number of shared segments and the size of the largest segment (in cM) will be listed on the DNA Match card under “DNA Match quality.” When reviewing the DNA Matches page, you can also sort your matches according to largest segment, which will conveniently place the matches with the largest segment of shared DNA at the top of the list.

Using the Chromosome Browser

The Chromosome Browser tool allows you to view a schematic graph of the DNA segments you share with your DNA Match. In many cases, you’ll see a Chromosome Browser graph at the bottom of the Review Match page. Right away, you’ll be able to tell whether you share long or short segments of DNA with the match.

If you want to dig deeper, you can use the One-to-Many Chromosome Browser tool in the DNA Tools section. This allows you to compare your DNA to that of multiple DNA Matches — which can help you get a clearer picture of who might be related to whom.

When you compare multiple DNA Matches, you might encounter triangulated segments: segments of DNA that all 3 (or more) of you have in common. If you have a triangulated segment with a known relative and a mystery DNA Match, that means that all of you likely share a common ancestor.

So if what you’re looking for is DNA Matches who are descended from a specific ancestor, it’s very helpful to have known relatives who are descended from that ancestor take a DNA test. That way, you can see on the Chromosome Browser which segments of DNA you share with that person, and that may help you infer whether additional DNA Matches who share those same segments are also descended from that ancestor.

If you test enough of that ancestor’s descendants, you may even begin to identify a particular segment of your DNA that seems to have been inherited from that ancestor. If you do, and you find another DNA Match who shares part of that DNA segment with you, you’ll be able to tell right away that they’re descended from that ancestor, too.

The limits of the Chromosome Browser method

There are limits to the Chromosome Browser method of identifying common ancestors, though, because we inherit a random mix of DNA from our parents.

Let’s demonstrate the problem in terms of ethnicity. Say your grandfather was 50% Italian and 50% Nigerian, and your grandmother was 100% Central Asian. Your dad and uncle each inherited 50% of your grandfather’s genes, but your dad may have inherited only the Italian genes, while your uncle inherited only the Nigerian genes. That would make your dad 50% Italian and 50% Central Asian, and your uncle 50% Nigerian and 50% Central Asian.

That means that your uncle’s child — your cousin — could have inherited 25% of his Nigerian genes from your grandfather, while you inherited 25% of your Italian genes from your grandfather. Both of you share 25% of your genes with your grandfather — but it’s a different 25%. And you and this cousin will still share 12.5% of your genes with each other — but they will be the ones inherited from your common grandmother, not your grandfather.

So if you compared your DNA to this cousin’s on the Chromosome Browser, you’d find that the gene segments you’ve identified as having been inherited from your grandfather don’t show up in his genes.

And that is where the AutoClusters DNA tool can help.

AutoClusters to the rescue

AutoClusters organizes your DNA Matches by “clusters” that indicate that they may share a common ancestor, based on the DNA they share both with you and with each other.

So let’s say your dad also has a sister, who inherited 25% of your grandfather’s Italian genes and 25% of his Nigerian genes. This aunt of yours also has a child, who inherited 12.5% of your grandfather’s Nigerian genes and 12.5% of his Italian genes. In this case, both of your cousins inherited Nigerian ethnicity from your grandfather, while you didn’t — and the 12.5% of DNA you share with one cousin is different from the 12.5% you share with the other. But because these cousins match each other, they will be “clustered” together with other descendants of your grandfather — helping you infer that they are, indeed, both descended from your grandfather.

Conclusion

Determining whether a DNA Match is a strong match depends on your genetic genealogy goals. Percentage of shared DNA, the length of the shared DNA segments, the location of triangulated segments with other matches, and AutoClusters can all provide you with vital clues that will help move you forward in your genetic genealogy journey.

To determine whether a given DNA Match will help you grow your tree, we recommend taking the following steps:

  • Check to see if there’s a Theory of Family Relativity™
  • Look at the user’s family tree and review shared Smart Matches™, DNA Matches, and ancestral surnames and places
  • Use the Chromosome Browser to examine how much DNA you share and the length and location of shared DNA segments
  • Compare the match to known relatives on the One-to-Many Chromosome Browser
  • Generate an AutoCluster and locate the cluster that contains the match
URL is copied to your clipboard.